All drives › Toshiba › 16 TB

Toshiba MG09ACA16TE 16 TB failure rate and reliability

C Grade C: Average

Backblaze logged 703 drive-years on the Toshiba MG09ACA16TE from Q1 2023 to Q3 2026, with 1,009 in service at the end of that period. In that time 12 drives failed, an annualised failure rate of 1.71%.

That is close to the 1.52% average across every drive in the same data, which earns it grade C (average).

Among the 8 graded 16 TB hard drives it ranks 6 of 8 for reliability.

Failure rate / year
1.71%
Average, all drives
1.52%
Drives in use
1,009
Drive-years
703
Failures
12
Capacity
16 TB
Type
HDD
Model number
MG09ACA16TE

Failure rate by quarter

QuarterDrive-daysFailuresFailure rate / year
Q3 202415100.00%
Q4 202491700.00%
Q1 20254,56800.00%
Q2 202512,70012.87%
Q3 202517,85200.00%
Q4 202528,20722.59%
Q1 202636,98810.99%
Q2 202668,42921.07%
Q3 202686,69062.53%

Single quarters with few drive-days swing widely; the overall figure above is the dependable one.

All 16 TB hard drives compared

GradeModelTypeSizeFailure rate / yearDrives in useDrive-yearsFailures
A Seagate ST16000NM002J HDD 16 TB 0.56% 463 1,607 9
B Western Digital WUH721816ALE6L4 HDD 16 TB 0.60% 26,751 87,781 529
B Seagate ST16000NM001G HDD 16 TB 0.62% 35,594 117,216 725
B Toshiba MG08ACA16TA HDD 16 TB 1.03% 38,772 121,800 1,260
B Toshiba MG08ACA16TE HDD 16 TB 1.14% 6,170 22,458 257
C Toshiba MG09ACA16TE HDD 16 TB 1.71% 1,009 703 12
C Western Digital WUH721816ALE6L0 HDD 16 TB 1.81% 2,896 10,953 198
D Toshiba MG08ACA16TEY HDD 16 TB 2.91% 4,767 19,015 554
– Seagate ST16000NM000J HDD 16 TB 2.23% 171 269 6
– Seagate ST16000NM005G HDD 16 TB 0.00% 25 94 0
– Toshiba MG11ACA16TE HDD 16 TB 0.00% 76 34 0